Re: What ruins bondage scenes in movies/TV for you?
Posted: Sat Feb 20, 2021 10:20 am
I'd say is when the victim is left alone and just sits there. In any real situation, if you'd been kidnapped and left alone tied up, you'd be doing absolutely everything you can to get free. The best scenes are the ones where the actors struggle for all they are worth and still can't get away - even better if we see someone have to untie them later. Without this, it kind of takes me out of the scene.
As an example, one of the best recent scenes I've seen concerns Valentina Padhe, from the German soap GZSZ. Not sure about the full context, but the general gist she's left tied to a radiator (hands tied behind) in an empty shop by a woman who's obsessed with her best friend. She's there for a full day and night and we see how she desperately struggles against her bonds to no avail, growing more frustrated and upset as the hours go on, and then later tries hopelessly to cut herself free. Eventually, she's found and rescued.
I think in that scene, it's clear that Valentina has been tied up for real and can't escape, which helps. I think some actors are more open to actually being tied up than others - I'm guessing it must be quite a challenging and awkward thing for an actor to agree to. I guess, even when actors aren't actually tied up as tightly as they appear, good camera work and direction can help with the scene.
As an example, one of the best recent scenes I've seen concerns Valentina Padhe, from the German soap GZSZ. Not sure about the full context, but the general gist she's left tied to a radiator (hands tied behind) in an empty shop by a woman who's obsessed with her best friend. She's there for a full day and night and we see how she desperately struggles against her bonds to no avail, growing more frustrated and upset as the hours go on, and then later tries hopelessly to cut herself free. Eventually, she's found and rescued.
I think in that scene, it's clear that Valentina has been tied up for real and can't escape, which helps. I think some actors are more open to actually being tied up than others - I'm guessing it must be quite a challenging and awkward thing for an actor to agree to. I guess, even when actors aren't actually tied up as tightly as they appear, good camera work and direction can help with the scene.